Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.
Had a wonderful experience with Wagner's Insurance Agency.Balaji R., Hummelstown, Pennsylvania“Had a wonderful experience with Wagner’s Insurance Agency. They helped me out in a tricky situation and dealt with everything patiently. It is so easy to get a hold of them and everything was processed immediately. Would definitely recommend them to everyone in Harrisburg area.
”- PCI have recommended them to family and friends.Peggy C., Hummelstown, Pennsylvania
“I switched to Wagner’s Insurance Agency for my auto insurance, resulting in a savings each month. My agent, Val is a wonderful, caring agent. I have recommended them to family and friends. Highly encourage using this agency!
” - I assure you that you will be happy with your decision.Ronda G., Hummelstown, Pennsylvania
“I would like to share my experience with Wagner Insurance (Hummelstown PA) /Erie Insurance. Recently, our teenage daughter was involved in a no fault collision. The Wagner/Erie team could not have been more compassionate, caring, and empathetic, while also being timely and efficient. From our local agent, (Dale/Wagner’s) to the claims agent (Jessica/Erie) to the assigned adjuster (Ramona/Erie), we could not have been more impressed with the service. Everyone was so personal and speedy. They seemed to truly care about our family and the anxiety and stress we were experiencing. We have been with Wagner’s Insurance for 33 years now. We have everything from car to home to life insurance with them. Fortunately, we have only occasionally had to use the services we have with them, but when we did, they were there with us the whole time. It is comforting to know there are big companies like Erie that still have the personal, small-town feel. We highly recommend them. If you are looking for a team that will take care of your claim expeditiously, while being caring and compassionate too, I encourage you to visit Wagner Insurance/ in Hummelstown PA/Erie Insurance. I assure you that you will be happy with your decision. I can guarantee it from our personal experience!”
- So glad to have these folks in my life !!!!Donna W., Hummelstown, Pennsylvania
“Wagner’s Insurance is the best insurance company i ever had. The people are outgoing, friendly and very helpful with any questions i may have.They were recommended by a friend of mine & it was the best change i have made 🙂
So glad to have these folks in my life !!!!” 
- Would definitely recommend them to everyone...Balaji R., Hummelstown, Pennsylvania
“Had a wonderful experience with Wagner’s Insurance Agency. They helped me out in a tricky situation and dealt with everything patiently. It is so easy to get a hold of them and everything was processed immediately. Would definitely recommend them to everyone in Harrisburg area.”
- Friendly, local, great customer service.Terri T., Hummelstown, Pennsylvania
“I cannot say enough good things about this agency: quick to respond to a claim or question. Contact with an adjuster within hours and we have never had a concern or issue with getting our claim check. Friendly, local, great customer service. You can’t go wrong with them. Thanks again! Hope we don’t need you anytime soon. :)”
- RZ
- DWDaulton W., Hummelstown, PA
“Matt has been an excellent insurance agent. He has been willing to help me at all times of the day and has ensured solutions to any problem I’ve had. Recently, my lien holder claimed to have not received my declarations page that Matt already sent 3 times. Within the hour he was on the phone with the financial institution and they were able to remedy the issue. This is one simple example of Matt’s commitment to excellent customer service and providing great efficiencies in his client’s day to day. That’s extremely important when you are as busy as I am! Thanks Matt!”
- ASAndrew S., Hummelstown, PA
“I worked with Matt. He was super helpful and responsive, which you don’t find at many places. On top of that, he was able to save me a bunch of money on my insurance policy! I definitely will/have been recommending people to contact Matt to see what he can do for them! Super happy customer!”
- MB
- LG
